By Gordon Pape, Editor and Publisher
Looking back, it’s hard to believe that 2020 marks 25 years of consecutive publication for our successful newsletter, Internet Wealth Builder (IWB).
The first preview issue appeared on November 12, 1996. To the best of my knowledge, it was the first financial newsletter in Canada, and perhaps in North America, to be exclusively delivered electronically.
In the spring of 1996, my son Kendrew suggested I start a newsletter, one that would be distributed via the internet. I remember my immediate reaction as if it were yesterday: “What’s the internet?”
By November, we were ready to roll out the first test issue of IWB. I had no idea what kind of reaction we would get (relatively few people had personal computers at that time), and our initial circulation was small, but we gradually evolved to a viable business by offering unbiased, quality guidance at a time when investors were eager to find new sources of information.
If you would like to revisit that first issue, it’s reproduced below.
In that first issue, I promised readers a newsletter that would be “interesting, at times exciting, and, most important, profitable to you personally”. I hope we have lived up to that commitment.
Internet Wealth Builder Premiere Issue
From November 12, 1996
Section 1 – Welcome!
Hi. Welcome to the Internet Wealth Builder, preview edition. I’m delighted
that you’ve decided to join us, and I hope that you’ll find this new
electronic newsletter interesting, at times exciting, and, most important,
profitable to you personally.
If you do, please tell any interested friends and encourage them to become a
member before the list is full. If the letter doesn’t live up to your
expectations, please tell me. My personal e-mail address is
firstname.lastname@example.org and I will try to answer communications from subscribers
as quickly as possible. However, I will be away on holiday during the last
two weeks of November so if there’s an urgent matter, send the message to
our circulation director, Kim (email@example.com).
This is the first test of the Internet Wealth Builder, in preparation for
our formal launch on Dec. 2. I expect there will be at least one more
preview issue before that time. Since you have received this transmission,
it means that you are on the official subscription list. No other
confirmation will be sent.
Because we are still in the beta phase, we would appreciate hearing about
any transmission problems you experience. Please send them to Kim at the
above e-mail address.
As I’ve been preparing for the launch of this letter, one huge advantage of
this form of communication has become apparent. Right now, brokerage houses
are awash with new issues of all types. Some are lousy, but a few look very
promising. The problem is that the best ones are usually snapped up before
the general public has a chance to hear about them. In some cases, the issue
is very small, so broker allocations are tiny. If it appears to be a good
deal, who do you think they’ll call? Their best clients, of course. No one
else will ever know.
This letter will enable you to short-circuit that cosy arrangement. I will
be keeping my eyes open for promising new issues, and advising you of them
regularly. If you read about something you think sounds interesting, get on
the phone to your broker the next day. Even if you’re not on his/her
favoured client list, the broker will have a hard time putting you off if
the firm is involved in the underwriting and there is still supply available.
This preview letter features one such new issue. I won’t be tracking its
performance because only a relatively small portion of our members will be
seeing this. But if you think this offer may interest you, go ahead and make
a call. Just be sure you understand the risks involved.
The other article today deals with the Veronika Hirsch case and what you
should do if you own units of the Fidelity True North Fund.
Hope you enjoy this bonus issue. Cheers for now.
Section 2 – Freehold Royalty Trust
Resource royalty trusts have become one of the investment world’s hottest
items over the past year.
There are two good reasons for that:
1) They offer attractive income flows at a time when interest rates are
falling like a stone.
2) Many of them have some terrific tax advantages.
One of the resource royalty trusts I recommended in The MoneyLetter,
Pengrowth Gas Income Fund, has increased in value by almost 27% in less than
18 months, while paying income of better than 10% annually based on the
original recommended price – all of which was tax sheltered!
There are a lot more stories like that. This is a hot area for investors.
Now there’s a new royalty trust issue available, one that I think has
tremendous promise. I am buying some for myself and I have recommended it to
other people in my family. It is not without risk – this isn’t some exotic
form of GIC. But if you’re looking for tax-deferred income and capital gains
potential, here it is.
It’s called the Freehold Royalty Trust. The history is colourful – the
origins of this trust can be traced all the way back to 1670, when Charles
II granted the Hudson’s Bay Company the sole trade and commerce rights to
huge chunks of land in western Canada. Over the years, the company retained
the rights to about 4.5 million acres in the three prairie provinces. It is
the mineral rights from those lands that form the basis of this trust.
When you buy into Freehold, you are buying a stake in the royalty income
from these lands. Most of this is generated by producing oil and gas wells,
although there is a small amount of revenue from potash mining as well.
This trust offers several advantages that similar royalty trusts don’t have:
1) Ownership is held in perpetuity. There’s no date when the rights revert
to the Crown or anyone else.
2) Payments are based on a percentage of production. In most other trusts,
they are a percentage of profits, which are clearly more vulnerable to
changes in economic conditions.
3) All the mineral titles are owned directly by Freehold. In most other
cases, the trust just owns a royalty right on the property.
4) Costs are very low. Freehold does not pay any operating costs or drilling
costs. These are paid for by the companies working the sites.
All these factors, and some others I don’t have space for here, add up to
potentially more distributable cash for unit holders. The illustration used
by the promoter is that if Freehold receives $19.50 for a barrel of oil,
distributable cash from that would be $18.75. For a conventional royalty
trust, distributable cash from that amount would be about $8.50.
Of course, Freehold takes that into account in the pricing of the units,
which at $10 represent a substantial premium of about 70% over the actual
valuation of the assets. So the price isn’t cheap.
Having said that, even at a $10 price the first year cash on cash
distribution will be 9.75% to 10.75%, depending on the final size of the
issue. And all distributions will be received on a tax sheltered basis until
the year 2000, at least.
That doesn’t mean you won’t ever have to pay tax. The complex tax
arrangements for these trusts result in your cost base being adjusted
downward for every penny of tax-sheltered income you receive. So if you
receive a $1 distribution in 1997, your $10 original price will be reduced
to $9 for purposes of calculating tax on any capital gain when you sell. Of
course if you never sell, it won’t matter.
The risks involved include a possible decline in oil and gas prices, wells
drying up (although the reserves here are unusually high), and the like. So
just because you get 9.75% – 10.75% in year one doesn’t mean you always
will. Distributions could be higher in the future – but they could be lower too.
Space doesn’t permit me to provide all the details. If you’re interested,
call your broker and ask for a prospectus. Some of the houses involved in
the distribution are RBC Dominion, Nesbitt Burns, CIBC Wood Gundy, Midland
Walwyn, and TD Securities.
Act fast. This deal is flying out the door. Allocations have been severely
rationed. It’s not something you can wait on.
Remember that if you place an order now, you can always change your mind
before the closing date (expected to be in early December).
Section 3 – True North Fund
Poor Veronika! I mean that sincerely. I think she’s been hung out to dry for
doing something that many other fund managers have done before. They just
didn’t get caught.
That said, if the allegations in the media are true, she appears to have
acted imprudently. It’s just one more example of why we need a code of
ethics for the industry.
But all this is being dissected in the media. If you’re a True North
investor, your concern is what to do now.
Fidelity has offered to redeem units without any sales charge until Nov. 13
(Wednesday). However, this may not be as good a deal as it sounds. I’ve
already received a message from one subscriber who tried to take advantage
of the offer through Green Line. They told him he could not sell his units
without charge since their 90-day penalty rule was still in effect (this is
a common rule with many discount brokers and no load fund companies who want
to discourage quick flips). He would have to pay the penalty for getting out
early, and he would not get back the 2% commission he had paid to acquire
the units in September. When he called Fidelity, he was told there was
nothing they could do since they count on their sales agents, like Green
Line, to implement the policy. Needless to say, he was miffed – and still
owns the fund.
Anyone else had a similar experience?
Of course, continuing to own True North won’t be a disaster. The replacement
manager is perfectly competent (as most Fidelity managers are). But he won’t
bring the flair that Hirsch has shown with her funds in the past. And he’s
based in Boston. One of the advantages of bringing Hirsch on board was that
Fidelity, for the first time, was going to set up an all-Canadian research
and investment team. No more!
If you can get out of True North for free, I suggest you do it since this is
no longer the fund you bought. You’ll probably exit with a small profit,
thanks to the recent market strength.
If it’s going to cost money to say goodbye, then hang in. See how Radlo (the
new manager) performs. If things don’t go well, you can always switch to
another Fidelity fund (hopefully without charge). There are plenty of good ones.
That’s it for this week. Be back soon.